No, not everything in life is predestined, at least not in the sense of a fixed script you are simply acting out. Some things do arrive without your permission: your family, your body, your temperament, the timing of certain events. But how you respond to them is not written in advance, and those responses shape what comes next. There are three common answers to this question. Here they are side by side, with my verdict.
Over the years, my exploration of astrology, spirituality, karma and human psychology has brought me back to one fundamental question: are we simply living a story written by destiny, or do our choices have the power to rewrite it? I believe life is a continuous interaction between circumstances we cannot control and decisions we are free to make. Destiny may present the circumstances, but our awareness, intentions and actions influence the journey ahead. In this article, I share three perspectives and invite you to question what you have always believed about destiny.
The three answers, compared
| 1. Everything is written | 2. Everything is your choice | 3. Given scene, chosen response | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it says | Life is a script. Effort only plays out what was always going to happen. | You create your reality. Anything is possible if you want it enough. | Circumstances are given; your response is free, and responses add up to the next circumstances. |
| Where you hear it | “Jo likha hai wahi hoga.” Some readings of astrology. | Motivational talks, hustle culture, manifestation books. | The Gita’s “your right is to the action, not its fruits”; karma theory; Vipassana. |
| What it gets right | Much of life really is outside our control. | Effort and attitude matter more than people admit. | Holds both: limits and responsibility. |
| Where it breaks | Becomes an excuse. “It was my destiny” ends every conversation about change. | Breeds guilt. Illness or loss becomes your fault for not trying hard enough. | Asks more of you. There is no one to blame and no promise of results. |
| How it feels to live by | Calm at first, then passive. | Energising at first, then exhausting. | Steadier. Less drama, more attention. |
My verdict
The third answer. In my book I put it as one cycle: destiny gives the situation, free will chooses the response, and the response becomes tomorrow’s destiny. You cannot choose the hand you are dealt. You can choose how you play it, and how you play it decides the next hand.
I part company with common advice on one point. People say “accept what you cannot change and change what you can” as if the line between the two were obvious. It rarely is. Most of us call a habit “destiny” because it has been repeated for so long that we no longer notice choosing it. The real work is finding that line honestly, again and again.
Philosophy has its own version of this middle path. Compatibilism, the view that free will and a world of causes can coexist, is a mainstream position among academic philosophers. And the Bhagavad Gita said something close to it long before, in chapter 2, verse 47: you have a right to your actions, never to their fruits.
How to use the verdict this week
- Pick one thing you keep calling fate. Write down which part arrived on its own and which part was your reaction.
- Notice the gap between a feeling and your response. Vipassana trained me to see it: it is small, but it is where free will actually lives.
- Judge your day by the quality of your actions, not by results. Results are partly destiny; actions are fully yours.
Where the book goes deeper
Destiny vs FreeWill began as a simple conversation between two friends and still reads like one. It draws on the Gita, the Upanishads and years of Vipassana practice, without preaching and without motivational hype. It goes into the questions this post only touches: why similar situations affect people so differently, why habits feel stronger than intention, why effort sometimes fails, and what “pain may be destiny; suffering is optional” means on an ordinary Monday. It became a #1 Amazon bestseller in Spiritual Self-Help. Start with what you control and what you don’t, or the reader questions I answered in seven questions before you buy it.
FAQ
Does astrology mean my life is already decided?
Not in the way I practise it. A chart describes tendencies and timing, the scene. It does not decide your response. I wrote about this in destiny gives the scene, free will writes the story.
If results are not in my control, why try?
Because effort changes the odds and, more importantly, changes you. The fruit is uncertain; the person who did the work is not.
What does karma have to do with destiny?
In the simplest reading, karma is the link between them: today’s actions become part of tomorrow’s circumstances. That is why the third answer is a cycle, not a fixed line.
If this question matters to you, read these next

Karmajyotir: the karma and astrology side of the same question. Also in Gujarati.
All my books are on the books page.
Tejash Shah is an Amazon bestselling author of 10 books, a Vipassana meditator and a certified astrology practitioner. Learn more about Destiny vs FreeWill.













